7 Best Seed Starting Mixes for your Garden 

 May 13, 2022

By  admin

If you’re starting seeds for the first time, it can be a little scary. There are several different types of seed mixes and each comes with its own set of instructions on how to use them. With so many options, which is best? In this article we break down 7 great mixes for beginners that will help you get your garden off to a healthy start!.

The “best seed starting mix recipe” is a list of the 7 best mixes for your garden.

There are affiliate links in this post. We may get a commission if you click and purchase, at no extra cost to you. For additional information, please visit our disclosure policy.

Seed starting may be difficult for anybody, whether a novice or a seasoned gardener. Most of the time, it’s the incorrect soil beginning mix that prevents seedlings from germinating properly. If you’re having trouble beginning seeds, our product review guide can assist you in selecting the best seed starting mix. 

Depending on the primary components, texture, consistency, water retention capacity, pH level, and other factors, a variety of seed starting mixes are available on the market. Investing in a seed starting mix, on the other hand, is critical for seed germination and subsequent development into adult plants. 

Seedling Mix Black Gold 1311002

Seedling Mix Black Gold 1311002

Our #1 Seed Starting Mix Recommendation!

This seeding mix combines Canadian Peat Moss Sphagnum, RESILIENCE, Perlite, and an organic wetting agent, and is great for sprouting seeds. This OMRI-listed mix is safe to use and enhances soil aeration and water retention, leading in speedier germination.

Price Comparison

*If you make a purchase, we will get a commission at no extra cost to you.

Working hard to find the ideal seed starting mix will never be in vain, from caring the seeds through vital germination phases to guaranteeing exceptional plant development.

Although the sort of seeds, your budget, and your personal tastes will all influence your decision, it is always preferable to be certain of the quality.

Continue reading for a more in-depth look at each of the seed starting mixtures mentioned above:

Reviews of the Top 7 Best Seed Starting Mixes

#1. Seedling Mix Black Gold 1311002

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • The ideal mix of elements
  • Consistency milled to perfection
  • The OMRI has listed
  • Packs of 4, 6, 10, and 16 quarts are available.

Black Gold Seedling Mix is ideal for sprouting vegetable, flower, and herbal seeds. It is designated by the Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI) because of its exceptional components. It’s also very polished and fine-textured. 

Canadian Peat Moss Sphagnum, RESiLIENCE (a brand name for a beneficial silicon component), Perlite, and an organic wetting agent are the major ingredients. Early blooming, improved root development, and enhanced resistance to bacterial infections and damping off have all been seen in plants cultivated in this mix. This seed starting mix also retains a lot of water.

Keep in mind, however, that this mix does not include any fertilizer to help the seedling grow. As a result, when the seed germinates, you may need to apply more fertilizer. 

Overall, it would be a wise investment for any gardening enthusiast, whether they are a novice or an expert propagator.

What We Enjoyed

  • Germination rate is excellent.
  • Seedlings get fatter and taller.
  • Texture and consistency are excellent.
  • Germination time is short.
  • Water retention capacity that is ideal

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Additional fertilizer is required.
  • Surprisingly costly

Check Amazon’s Current Price

Burpee Organic Coir de Coco Concentrated Seed Starting Mix is number two. 

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • Brick made from seed starting mix
  • Coconut husk is the main ingredient.
  • Simple to work with

Burpee Organic Coir de Coco Concentrated Seed Starting Mix is essentially a compacted block of coconut husk. Unlike other seed beginning mixes on the market, it requires the addition of water to make 8 quarts of wet seed starting mix. It’s simple to use and transforms into a fine-textured mix when hydrated. 

One of its best features is that it is made from 100 percent natural material. Hence, being biodegradable and environment friendly, it is The OMRI has listed. Its main constituent is Coir de Coco, which is a significantly sustainable material as compared to Peat. Moreover, it would decompose completely, leaving behind no residue upon decomposition. 

It greatly facilitates seed germination and root development by maintaining appropriate aeration. Mostly because it can store a lot of water. It also has a pH level of neutral. It does not, however, include any nutritional or fertilizer content. As a result, after the seeds germinate and develop into seedlings, you’ll need to apply diluted liquid fertilizer.

What We Enjoyed

  • 100 percent natural material
  • Encourages root development
  • Very light and fluffy, which helps with aeration.
  • Compact, but expands dramatically when water is added.
  • Cheaper 

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Mold/insect infestation was reported by several users. 
  • Additional fertilizer is required.

Check Amazon’s Current Price

Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix (#3)

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary

  • Contains a lot of nutrients
  • Excellent water retention ability
  • It’s light and fluffy.
  • Packs of 8 quarts are available.

This seed starting mix is ideal for novices since it is simple to use and produces good results. It’s a premium combination that includes Peat Moss Sphagnum, perlite, and other elements that help the seeds germinate properly.

The mix has been particularly prepared to promote rapid root growth. It also has the appropriate fertilizer content to aid plant development. Even better, the seedlings grow tall and sturdy and have a high germination rate. Keep in mind that the mixture has a good water retention capacity and was intended to be used in containers. 

One difficulty with Miracle-Gro is that it may include big twigs or debris that must be manually removed before sowing the seeds.

What We Enjoyed

  • Outstanding germination outcomes
  • Encourages rapid germination
  • Fertilizer is included.
  • Water retention capacity that is ideal

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Some twigs must be gathered by hand. 
  • Some seeds may not be compatible.

Check Amazon’s Current Price

#4. Jiffy Natural & Organic Starter Mix

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • 100 percent natural
  • Ingredients that are essential
  • Mixture of greenhouse quality
  • Packs of ten quarts are available.

Jiffy Natural & Organic Starter Mix is a pretty good choice in terms of water retention, basic ingredients, seedling quality, and texture. It does well on almost all the parameters.

Vermiculite, Peat Moss, and Lime are the three main constituents of this product. Peat Moss assists in water retention and aeration, Vermiculite avoids soil compaction and may store a lot of water, and Lime changes the medium’s pH level. Remember that jiffy’s seed starting mix produces strong, robust seedlings.

It should be noted, however, that this mixture must be combined with water before the seeds are planted. If not, it may seem to resist water. Most significantly, when the seedling has grown, fertilizer should be provided expressly.

What We Enjoyed

  • 100 percent natural ingredients
  • Texture and consistency are excellent.
  • Beginner friendly
  • Excellent seedling development

What We Didn’t Care For

  • It must first be combined with water.
  • Fertilizer is not included.

Check Amazon’s Current Price

#5 Espoma SS16 Premium Organic Seed Starter Potting Mix

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • Strong seedlings as a result
  • Germination rates are high and fast.
  • Chemical-free and organic
  • Packs of 8 quarts are available.

Espoma Organic Seed Starter Potting Mix is a versatile seed starter mix that may be used for a wide range of seeds. 

Peat Moss Sphagnum, perlite, limestone, and yucca extract make about 80-90 percent of the mixture. It also includes Myco-tone, which is a mix of active fungal components that Encourages root growth, water retention, and reduces transplant shock. Similarly, the mix provides enough fertilizer and nutrients to nourish the plants.

One potential flaw with this product is that it seems to be too coarse for tiny seeds. It “has a great germination rate but is difficult to utilize owing to the detritus it includes,” according to users. As a result, it is recommended that you spend some time sifting the mix before using it.

What We Enjoyed

  • Long-term performance of seedlings
  • Strong growth
  • Fertilizer is included.
  • Ideal for watering the ground.

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Texture is coarse, making it unsuitable for small seeds.
  • Surprisingly costly

Check Amazon’s Current Price

Purple Cow Organics Seed Starter Mix is number six.

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • The OMRI has listed
  • Seeds germinate quickly.
  • 12-quart bags, Cubic Footbags, and 2 Cubic Yard super sacks are also available.

Purple Cow Organics Seed Starter Mix provides various advantages due to its excellent quality composition, including enhanced germination rates, solid seedlings, and cost-effective pricing. It’s a fine-textured natural and organic combination. Plants may be grown in trays, blocks, or tiny pots using it.

Purple Cow Compost, Peat Moss Sphagnum, Perlite, Vermiculite, rock and marine minerals, and important fertilizer content are all included in the mix. This unique mixture balances water retention and drainage, promotes root growth, and lowers water loss. 

Although this is a good alternative, it is crucial to note that the fertilizer concentration in the mix may cause weed growth in the pots. 

What We Enjoyed

  • Organic material
  • High-Top-notch seedlings
  • It’s light and fluffy.
  • Top-notch seedlings 

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Quite costly
  • Weed growth was noted by some users.

#7. Hoffman Seed Starter Soil 30103

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary 

  • High germination rate
  • milled finely
  • It’s also good for transplanting.
  • Bags of ten quarts are available.

This seed starting mix is an excellent buy since it can be used to develop microgreens and a variety of seeds. It moistens really rapidly and has a very good germination rate also. What strikes us the most is how nicely the plants cultivated in this mixture develop. Furthermore, the fine texture of the mix facilitates seed sprouting.

Canadian Peat Moss Sphagnum, Vermiculite, limestone, and a wetting agent are the main constituents. This soilless mix provides the seedlings with an adequate physical habitat and nourishes them.

This product is rather good, albeit it may burn a little hole in certain people’s pockets. 

What We Enjoyed

  • Ingredient proportions are perfect.
  • Exceptional seed germination
  • Fine texture and light weight
  • Water is appropriately retained.

What We Didn’t Care For

  • Molds and fungus gnats were reported by some individuals.
  • It may not be appropriate for all kinds of seeds.

Sun Gro 1311002 8-Quart Seedling Mix is ranked #8.

Check Amazon’s Current Price

a brief summary

  • Ideal for germination of organic seeds
  • Packs of 4, 6, and 10 quarts are available.
  • Mixture for premium seedlings

Black Gold Seedling Mix is the way to go if you’re seeking for an organic seed germination mix. It’s a robust seeding mix that’s OMRI-listed and perfect for seed germination, pruning, and seedling development.

70-80 percent Canadian Peat Moss Sphagnum, perlite, dolomite lime, and yucca extract make up the 8-quart container. This combination is quite light and simple to use because to the presence of perlite. This mix will also give your seedlings with the essential ventilation and water retention for optimal root development.

Remember that this seeding mix is exclusively for propagating cuttings in plastic flats, trays, and pots. Because it is organic, it is also safe to use for germinating fruits and vegetables.

However, this mixture lacks the minerals required for seed health. As a consequence, nutritional supplements and soil amendments may become more expensive.

What We Enjoyed

  • Promotes healthy plant development.
  • Fruit and vegetable plants thrive in this environment.
  • Lightweight
  • Aeration and hydration to the soil are made easier.
  • It’s ideal for beginning seedlings.
  • Encourages root growth 
  • Environmentally friendly

Check Amazon’s Current Price

Consider These Factors Before Purchasing Seed Starting Mixes

Now that you’re aware of all the greatest possibilities, you’ll want to make sure your selected seed starting mix meets specific criteria before committing your seeds to it. 

As a result, below is a list of parameters to look for while looking for the ideal seed starting mix:

1. Components

When choosing a seed starting mix, the first and most important consideration should be the ingredients. Always double-check that it has at least a few important elements, some of which are mentioned below:


This is a light, absorbent, and spongy kind of mica that has been specially processed. Its main purpose is to keep water in place. It has a pH of 7 and is initially neutral, although it may slightly elevate the pH of the soil combination. 

Horticultural vermiculite is also recognized for absorbing nutrients and other soil constituents and gradually releasing them to the plants.


Perlite, unlike Vermiculite, is utilized for water drainage. It increases improved oxygen availability to the roots and improves aeration. It also aids in the removal of surface crusting and excess moisture.

Peat Moss Sphagnum

This makes for a sterile and absorbent seed starting medium. Sphagnum moss holds water and promotes improved root growth. It’s also known for its antibacterial qualities, which help seedlings resist bacterial infections.

Coir de Coco

It is widely used as an environmentally safe alternative to Peat Moss Sphagnum. It promotes water retention and provides the perfect conditions for a seed to germinate. 

pH Adjusting Agents

To maintain an appropriate pH level of roughly 5.5 to 6.5, extra materials like Limestone are often included to seed starting mixes. 


Even though a seed includes all of the nourishment it needs to sprout, a seed starting mix with a certain quantity of nutritional content and soil components is recommended.

2. Irritability

This criterion ensures that the seed starting mix is devoid of any potentially dangerous bacteria, soil-borne illnesses, fungus, or other contaminants that might prevent the seeds from germinating properly. It also assures that no competing weed seeds are present in the soil mix. It goes without saying that sterilized seed starting mix is highly recommended.

When you purchase seed starting mix, it usually has a “sterilized” label on it. As a result, when selecting a seed starting mix, use one that has already been sterilized. It also appears fair to choose one that is listed by the Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI). 

3. Water retention that is appropriate

Water retention is another important element to consider. The seed starting mix you choose should be able to absorb and retain enough moisture to allow the seed to sprout. It should, however, be able to drain rapidly, allowing room for critical air circulation between the damp seeds.

Check to determine if the seed starting mix contains any of the elements mentioned above that are known to help with water retention. 

4. Organic and long-term

It’s important to use an organic soil mix when beginning seedlings, not only because it’s better for the environment, but also because it leads to real organic farming. Using organic goods would result in far less environmental waste, and the nutrients would be returned to the land as they decomposed.

5. Texture

The selected seed starting mix should be Lightweight, uniform, and milled finely. There should be no coarse chunks, chips, or long strings of coir. This would allow the young roots to bind with the soil particles easily and decently germinate.


To summarize, in order to make the best option, you must be familiar with numerous seed starting mixtures, from their brands to their specifications, component combinations, and so on. By researching and comparing the best possibilities, you may expedite your search for the best seed starting mix for your requirements with our product reviewal guide. 

Our favourite pick as the best seed starting mix is Seedling Mix Black Gold 1311002. Its unique blend, fine texture, Organic material, and antibacterial properties make it the best fit for seed starting. 

Nonetheless, based on your budget and particular gardening needs, you may choose the finest alternative. Whatever choice you select, be sure you use the information above to make an informed decision. 

We hope that sowing seeds and seeing them grow brings you delight. Happy gardening!

The “best organic seed starter mix” is a great way to start your garden. If you want to know what the best seed starting mix for your garden, then this article will help.

Related Tags

  • best seed starting mix for tomatoes
  • espoma seed starting mix
  • black gold seed starting mix
  • make your own seed starting mix
  • best seed starting mix for peppers

Emil Schoene

Born and raised in Austin, TX I come from a background of home renovation. By helping my family in my younger years with their construction business, I learned the ropes quickly and as I grew it became my passion that I still do today. Looking to share my knowledge with others. I invite you to leave comments on any post as I know you will have questions that you are not finding anywhere else.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}